Okay, I lived with it for a couple of weeks. Occasionally I'd drag Ben into the bathroom with me and make him analyze the gray walls. Sigh, we were in agreement: no matter how much we love that shade of gray, it does not work in this bathroom.
Back to the paint chips we went. This time Emily selected Cappuccino White by Glidden.
I'm not in love with it, but it does match the tile.
We are pretty much back to singing our favorite refrain around here so we can get the walls ready for a new new coat of paint.
...Wipe, sand, spackle, sand, wipe, spackle, sand...